Creature Cock Butt Plug Sets: Silicone vs Metal

By Le Wand: Best Wand Vibrators and Sex Toys for Solo & Couples | Published: 2026-10-23

Category: Product Reviews

Compare the Creature Cocks Green Eyes Silicone Butt Plug Set and the Creature Cock Sinister Eyes Metal Butt Plug Set to find your perfect match based on material, comfort, and training goals.

Quick answer

Choose the Creature Cocks Green Eyes Silicone Butt Plug Set if you prioritize comfort and gradual training; opt for the Creature Cock Sinister Eyes Metal Butt Plug Set if you prefer a firmer, heavier feel and a more intense stretch.

Material matters: silicone vs metal for anal training

The biggest difference between these two Creature Cock sets is the material. Silicone is flexible, warm to the touch, and offers a forgiving feel that helps beginners or those sensitive to pressure. Metal is rigid, dense, and can provide a more pronounced sensation of fullness and weight.

Both materials are body-safe—silicone is non-porous and easy to clean, while the nickel-free metal is also non-porous and can be used with any lubricant type. Your choice comes down to the experience you want: gentle and adaptable versus firm and weighty.

Visual appeal: fantasy aesthetics

Both sets feature a striking fantasy design with an eye motif. The Green Eyes set uses a vivid green cat-eye that stands out against the silicone, while the Sinister Eyes set incorporates a mesmerizing glass eye set into metal. If you enjoy a bold, playful look during solo or partner play, either set offers a unique visual element.

Trade-offs to consider

Comfort vs intensity: Silicone's flexibility makes it more forgiving during insertion and wear, reducing the risk of discomfort. Metal's rigidity delivers a more pronounced, intense feeling of fullness.
Weight and sensation: Metal plugs are heavier, which can enhance the feeling of being filled and may provide subtle internal pressure. Silicone plugs are lighter and may be easier to wear for longer periods. If you want a plug that stays put without constant awareness, silicone might be better; if you want a constant reminder of the toy, metal could be your pick.
Lubricant compatibility: Silicone plugs require water-based lubricant to avoid degrading the material. Metal plugs work with any lubricant, including silicone-based, which lasts longer. If you prefer longer-lasting lube, the metal set offers more flexibility.

Product facts at a glance

Creature Cocks Green Eyes Silicone Butt Plug Set: Includes small, medium, and large sizes made from high-quality, body-safe silicone. The graduated sizing lets you train gradually, and the silicone flexes for a more comfortable insertion, ideal for those new to anal play.
Creature Cocks Green Eyes Silicone Butt Plug Set
Creature Cock Sinister Eyes Metal Butt Plug Set: Made from nickel-free metal with a glass eye, available in three progressive sizes. The firm, heavy metal provides a distinct stretch and weight, and the nickel-free construction ensures it's safe for most users with metal sensitivities.
Creature Cock Sinister Eyes Metal Butt Plug Set

Which set is right for you?

Best for

Beginners or those who want a gentler, more flexible training experience (silicone set)
Users who enjoy a heavy, firm sensation and want to use any lubricant type (metal set)

Not ideal for

Those who prefer a very lightweight toy (avoid metal set)
Users who only use silicone-based lubricants and want a silicone toy (silicone set requires water-based lube)